"D.R. Horton, one of the nation’s largest home builders, posted a third-quarter loss after writing down the value of unused land and warned there was no recovery in sight for the troubled housing industry."
"Another home builder, Beazer Homes USA, which faces federal investigations of company practices and personnel, also said it swung to a loss in its fiscal third quarter after cutting prices to spur sales and taking charges to write down the value of unsold inventory."
My prediction has come to fruition. I reported this last month:
"Their respective inventories will continue to decrease in value as the housing bust runs its course and prices subside. Inventory makes up 73 percent of total assets for KB Homes, 77 percent of total assets for Lennar, and 83 percent of total assets for DR Horton. As inventories decrease in value, so should the stock prices."
This will continue to happen over plenty more quarters. The losses reported will get deeper and deeper and unlike my thoughts last month, some major homebuilders will file for bankruptcy. This has to do with the fact that homebuilders began forecasting future projections based on super-inflated numbers and made speculative bets based on those inflated numbers.
Of course there are those people who think it has nothing to do with fundamentals; rather, it has to do with psychology:
"'It's a psychological problem right now, more than anything else,' Hovnanian said on CNBC's 'Squawk Box.' 'Job growth is good. Interest rates are still really, really good. Demographics are good so it will come around.'"
"'We've been through these cycles many, many times before,' he continued. 'When it's bad everybody thinks it's going to be bad forever, and that’s not the case. It is going to come around.'"
I agree with Ara about the fact that it won't be bad forever, but I do think that there are some homebuilders that are extremely overextended. Ara insists that interest rates are low and job growth is good, but he fails to see two points:
(1) Job growth means nothing without wage growth. We can create millions of new jobs, but if they're all minimum wage jobs, then what's the point? It wouldn't bode well for the housing market unless they feel like making more subprime mortgage loans.
(2) Interest rates are at historical lows, but they're not low if you look at the last eight to ten years. The reason homebuilders and the housing market were able to persist after the recession at the turn of the century can be attributed to Alan Greenspan and his psycho-crazy idea of setting interest rates below the rate of inflation. He saved the economy temporarily, while putting off the major recession until later.
To recap, I think the recent housing downturn has more to do with fundamentals of the economy than it does with the psychology of the average prospective homebuyer. I think that the value of land will continue it's slide for years to come, creating lower book values for homebuilders who are overextended, which in turn creates downward pressure on homebuilder stocks. Don't miss out on this easy opportunity.
No comments:
Post a Comment